關於Zara平替香水(替瓶)清單與看法
浙江大學
主要是給想買香水,但又覺得昂貴的人,整理的平替香水心得分享
----------------------------
zara
----------------------------
常見的三大平替品牌:
zara、armaf、lattafa
其中zara是一家西班牙品牌
有800多種不同的香水
其中200瓶氣味似抄襲其他商業香水
因此可作為替瓶
下方引用wicked-good.co網站
整理的替瓶資料
----------------------------
zara 平替清單
----------------------------
- A Perfume
= Byredo Bal d’Afrique 熱帶爵士
- A Sweet Pastry In Paris
= Maison Margiela Replica By The Fireplace 溫暖壁爐
- Accord No. 02 Oriental
= Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille 午夜香草
- Amalfi Sunray
= Tom Ford Neroli Portofino 暖陽橙花
- Amber & Fig Cashmere
= Hermès Eau des Merveilles橘采星光
- Amber Ego
= Emporio Armani Stronger With You 你讓我堅強
- Amber Ego
= Tom Ford Amber Absolute 絕對琥珀
- Amber Fusion
= Prada L'Homme 蔚藍紳士
- Amber Fusion
= Xerjoff Erba Pura 純淨草木
- Amber Linen
= Byredo Bal d’Afrique 熱帶爵士
- Amber Vanilla
= Thierry Mugler Alien Essence Absolue 異形定制版
- Ambre Inspirant Perfume Oil
= Lolita Lempicka L de Lolita Lempicka 海洋之心
- Ancestral Papyrus
= Maison Crivelli Papyrus Moléculaire
- Applejuice
= Chanel Chance Eau Tendre 粉紅甜蜜
- Aromatic Future
= Dior Sauvage 曠野之心
- Azul Noche
= Dior Midnight Poison 午夜奇葩藍毒
- Barbie
= Kilian Love Don’t Be Shy 大膽愛
- Bergamot & Leather Spritz
= Dior Homme 傑傲
- Bergamot and Leather Spritz
= Le Labo Another 13 別樣13
- Black Amber
= Dolce & Gabbana The One 唯我
- Black Dart = Gucci Rush 狂愛
- Black Peony
= Viktor & Rolf Flowerbomb 鮮花炸彈
- Black Pepper & Cedarwood
= Creed Royal Oud 皇家沉香
- Black Tag
= Armani White 白色女士
- Blue Candy
= Thierry Mugler Angel
- Blue Hole
= Davidoff Cool Water 冷水男士
- Blue Spirit
= Paco Rabanne Invictus 勇者
- Bohemian Bluebells
= Diptyque Do Son 杜桑
- Bohemian Oud
= Maison Martin Margiela Replica By The Fireplace 溫暖壁爐
- Bohemian Sunset In Barcelona
= Armani Acqua Di Gio Essenza 寄情男士精粹版
- Bois Soleil
= Mancera Wild Python 野蟒
- Boldly Seoul
= Jo Malone Mimosa + Cardamom 含羞草與小荳蔻
- Bright Rose
= Narciso Rodriguez For Her 她的同名女士
- Candy Festival
= Louis Vuitton Afternoon Swim 午後漫遊
- Captivatingly Paris
= Givenchy Irresistible 傾城之魅
- Cashmere Rose
= Gucci Flora by Gucci Gorgeous Gardenia 幻夢梔子花
- Caviar Bergamot
= Acqua di Parma Blu Mediterraneo Bergamotto di Calabria 藍色地中海
- Cerise Peonies
= Acqua di Parma Peonia Nobile 高貴牡丹
- Cherry Sling
= Gucci Flora by Gucci Eau Fraiche 花之舞
- Cherry Smoothie
= Tom Ford Lost Cherry 失落櫻桃
- Classic 9.0
= Valentino Uomo 同名男士
- Coastal Salty Forest
= Profumum Roma Acqua di Sale 賽爾之水
- Cotton Kiss / A Perfume in Rose
= Glossier You 你
- Creatively Shanghai
= Guerlain Aqua Allegoria Mandarine Basilic 柑橘羅勒
- Crispy Gardenia
= YSL Black Opium Neon 黑鴉片果味版
- Dark Emerald
= Juicy Couture Viva la Juicy Gold Couture 金色限量版
- Dear Iris
= Carolina Herrera Good Girl 好女孩
- Deep Garden
= Carolina Herrera Good Girl 好女孩
- Deep Garden
= Chloé Nomade 蔻依 芳心之旅
- Delicious Blossom
= Armani Si 挚爱
- Ebony Wood
= Byredo Gypsy Water 吉普賽之水
- Ebony Wood
= Jo Malone Wood Sage And Sea Salt
鼠尾草與海鹽香水
- Elegant Opulence
= Emporio Armani Stronger With You Intensely 你讓我堅強加強版
- Elegantly Tokyo
= Mugler Cologne Run Free 穆勒自由驰骋
- Emotions N°01 Vetiver Pamplemousse
= Jo Malone Grapefruit 葡萄柚
- Emotions N°02 Waterlily Tea Dress
= Jo Malone Wild Bluebell 藍風鈴
- Emotions N°03 Ebony Wood
= Le Labo Santal 33 檀香 33
- Emotions N°04 Amalfi Sunray
= Acqua di Parma Blu Mediterraneo Fico di Amalfi 藍色地中海無花果
- Emotions N°05 Tubereuse Noir
= Tom Ford Black Orchid 黑蘭花
- Emotions N°06 Fleur d'Oranger
= Jo Malone Orange Blossom 橙花
- Emotions N°07 Fleur De Patchouli
= Chanel Coco Mademoiselle 可可小姐
- Emotions N°08 Ebony Wood
= Byredo Gypsy Water 吉普賽之水
- Endless Oud
= Gucci Guilty Absolute 罪愛絕對
- Energetically New York
= Le Labo Santal 33 檀香 33
- Evening Maiden Orchid
= YSL Libre Eau de Toilette 自由不羈
- Evening Safari Drive
= Diptyque Tam Dao 譚道
- Exclusive Oud
= Armani Privé Oud Royal 皇家沉香
- Exotic Mimosa
= Kenzo Summer 晨曦新露
- Extreme 12.0
= Chanel Allure Homme Sport 運動男性
- Extreme 6.0
= YSL L’Homme Parfum Intense 天之驕子
- Extreme Fusion
= Jean Paul Gaultier Le Beau 冰風暴
- Fabulous Sweet
= Paco Rabanne Lady Million Fabulous 绝妙的百萬女士
- Fashionably London
= Delina Exclusif 高尚殿藏
- Femme
= Dior Hypnotic Poison 紅毒藥
- Femme
= Narciso Rodriguez For Her 她的同名女士
- Fields at Nightfall
= Zadig & Voltaire This is Her
- Fig = Hermès Un Jardin en Méditerranée 地中海花園
- Fleur d’Oranger
= Jo Malone Orange Blossom 橙花
- Fleur De Baies
= Le Labo Baie 19 樹果19
- For Him
= Armani Code Profumo 致命密碼
- For Him Red Edition
= Maison Francis Kurkdjian Baccarat Rouge 540 Extrait de Parfum 水晶之焰
- Forget Me Not
= Dolce & Gabbana Light Blue 淺藍女士
- Frosted Cream
= Montblanc Signature 純白印記
- FRSH 003/FRV
= Dolce & Gabbana Light Blue 淺藍女士
- Full Moon Over The Desert
= Memo Paris Irish Leather 愛爾蘭-風之鞍
- Gardenia
= YSL Black Opium 黑鴉片
- Go Fruity
= Burberry Her 博柏利女性
- Golden Decade
= YSL Libre 自由不羈
- Golden Decade
= YSL Libre Intense 自由不羈加強板
- Gourmand Addict
= Paco Rabanne Olympea 女神
- Gourmand Addict
= Prada Candy 蜜糖香吻
- Gourmand Leather
= Jean Paul Gaultier Ultra Male 超級男士
- Gracefully Madrid
= Maison Francis Kurkdjian Aqua Universalis 永恆之水
- Hibiscus
= Loewe Solo Ella 獨奏宣言女士
- Hipster Oud
= Delina Exclusif 高尚殿藏
- Hypnotic Vanilla
= Jean Paul Gaultier Scandal le Parfum 醜聞女士
- Imperial Purple
= Valentino Uomo Intense Valentino同名男性
- Infinite Wave
= Issey Miyake L’Eau d’Issey Pour Homme 一生之水
- Lasting Desire
= Paco Rabanne Invictus Victory 勇者無敵
- Le Petit Lullaby
= Goutal Petite Cherie 小甜心
- Les Heures Passent
= Louis Vuitton Imagination 思揚
- Lightly Bloom
= Miss Dior Blooming Bouquet 花漾迪奧
- Lilac and Cinnamon
= Jo Malone Myrrh & Tonka 沒藥與零陵香
- Lisboa Colombo Avenida do Colegio Militar
= Armani Acqua Di Gio 寄情水
- Lisbon
= Diptyque Philosykos 希臘無花果
- London
= Burberry My Burberry 我的博柏利
- London Saville Row Mayfair
= Yves Saint Laurent Y 聖羅蘭Y
- Los Angeles 6902 Hollywood Boulevard
= Givenchy Gentleman 紳士
- Luminous Flowers
= Estée Lauder Pleasures 歡沁
- Majestic Opulence
= Lancôme La Vie Est Belle Intensément美麗人生加強版
- Man Blue Spirit
= Paco Rabanne Invictus 勇者
- Man Gold
= Paco Rabanne Black XS 黑騎士
- Man Silver
= Giorgio Armani Acqua Di Gio 寄情水
- Man Silver
= Gucci Guilty Pour Homme 罪愛
- Man Uomo
= Paco Rabanne 1 Million 百萬金磚
- Marshmallow Addiction
= Escada Rockin’ Rio 搖滾森巴
- Memoire Intense
= Lancôme Idôle L’Intense 偶像 加強板
- Memorable Aura
= Alien Goddess 外星女神
- Memorable Aura
= Paco Rabanne Fame 名譽
- Milan = Armani Si 挚爱
- Mimosa Cloud
= Ariana Grande Cloud 亞莉安娜雲朵
- Morning Grasse
= Frédéric Malle Lipstick Rose 玫瑰唇印
- Mountain Woody Forest
= Le Labo Santal 33 檀香 33
- MSK 004/NTL
= Lancôme Iris Dragées 香甜鳶尾
- Mystery Balance
= Jo Malone Wild Bluebell 藍風鈴
- Navy Black
= Chanel Bleu de Chanel 香奈爾 蔚藍
- New York
= Calvin Klein Eternity 永恆男性
- Night Pour Homme II
= Dior Sauvage 曠野之心
- Night Pour Homme II Winter
= Jean Paul Gaultier Le Male In The Navy 裸男海軍服
- Night Pour Homme III
= Dior L’Homme Parfum Intense 傑傲
- Night Pour Homme V
= Maison Francis Kurkdjian Baccarat Rouge 540 水晶之焰
- Nightfall Blue
= Dior Sauvage 曠野之心
- Nocturnal Life
= By Kilian Angels’ Share 天使之享
- Nude Bouquet
= Miss Dior 花漾迪奧
- Nude Bouquet
= Miss Dior Blooming Bouquet 花漾迪奧
- Nude Cashmere
= Byredo Palermo 巴勒莫
- Orchid = Victoria’s Secret Bombshell
- Oriental = Viktor & Rolf Flowerbomb 鮮花炸彈
- Oriental = YSL Opium 黑鴉片
- Paris
= Lancôme La Nuit Trésor 璀璨星夜
- Perpetual Oud
= Maison Francis Kurkdjian Oud Satin Mood 絲緞情懷
- Pink Flambé
= Juicy Couture Viva La Juicy 甜美萬歲
- Pink Flambé Winter
= Chloé Love 蔻依 愛情故事
- Powdery Magnolia
= Chloé Eau de Parfum 蔻依edp
- Radiant Bloom
= Hermès H24
- Red Temptation
= Maison Francis Kurkdjian Baccarat Rouge 540 水晶之焰
- Red Temptation Elixir
= Maison Francis Kurkdjian Baccarat Rouge 540 Extrait de Parfum 水晶之焰
- Red Temptation Summer
= Ex Nihilo Fleur Narcotique 花之迷醉
- Red Temptation Winter
= Mancera Instant Crush 即時粉碎
- Red Vanilla
= Lancôme La Vie Est Belle 美麗人生
- Regal White
= Etat Libre d’Orange Fat Electrician
- Rich Leather
= Creed Aventus 拿破崙
- Rose = Dior J’Adore 真我
- Rose Gold
= Michael Kors 米高歌斯
- Rose Gourmand
= Lancôme Trésor Midnight Rose 珍爱午夜玫瑰
- Rose Gourmand
= Montale Paris Intense Café 情迷咖啡
- Rose Marshmallow Candy
= Kilian Love, Don’t Be Shy 濃情一刻
- Rose Petal Drops
= Parfums de Marly Delina 高尚
- S4nd4lwood
= Le Labo Santal 33 檀香 33
- Saffron & Orange Flowers
= Elie Saab Le Parfum
- Salty Ocean Bouquet
= Calvin Klein CK2 卡文克萊CK2
- Sand Desert At Sunset
= Kilian Angels’ Share 天使之享
- Santal Glow
= Byredo Mojave Ghost 莫哈维之影
- Scent #2
= Dior Sauvage 曠野之心
- Sense of Glam
= Frédéric Malle Lipstick Rose
- Seoul 532-8 Sinsa Dong Gangnam-Gu
= Maison Margiela Replica Jazz Club 爵士俱樂部
- Shanghai = Gucci Bloom 花悦
- Silver = Paco Rabanne Invictus 勇者
- Soft Haze
= Creed Silver Mountain Water 銀色山泉
- Soleil Decade
= Estée Lauder Bronze Goddess 璀璨女神
- Splendid Bronze = Mugler Alien 異形
- Starlight Vanilla = Kayali Vanilla 28
- Stunningly Venice
= Parfums de Marly Meliora 美麗蘿拉
- Sublime Epoque
= Armani My Way 自我無界
- Sultry Pear
= Jean Paul Gaultier La Belle 自我無界
- Summer Collection
= Dolce & Gabbana Light Blue 淺藍女士
- Summer Collection Zara
= Hugo Boss Bottled Unlimited 無限
- Sunrise On The Red Sand Dunes
= Louis Vuitton Imagination 思揚
- Surfing Mullaghmore Head
= Paco Rabanne Invictus Aqua 勇者之水
- Teahupoo
= Paco Rabanne Invictus Aqua 勇者之水
- Tender Amber
= Tiziana Terenzi Kirké
- The Golden Lullaby
= Juliette Has A Gun Pear Inc 青梨狂想
- Thursday – No Valentines But Flowers
= Carolina Herrera Very Good Girl 無畏女王
- Tobacco Collection Intense Dark Exclusive = Carolina Herrera 212 VIP Men
- Tobacco Collection Rich Warm Addictive
= Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille 午夜香草
- Tobacco Collection Unexpected Fresh Spicy = Parfums de Marly Oajan 奥杰
- Tokyo
= Maison Margiela Replica Sailing Day 航海日
- Tonic Impact
= Paco Rabanne Phantom 幻影
- Tropical Boost
= Marc Jacobs Perfect 玩美小姐
- True Amore
= Parfums de Marly Delina 高尚
- True Leather
= Memo Paris Irish Leather 愛爾蘭-風之鞍
- Tubereuse Noir = Gucci Bloom 花悦
- Tuberose = Dior J'adore 真我
- Twilight Mauve
= DKNY Be Delicious 青蘋果
- Twilight Mauve
= Estée Lauder Modern Muse 現代繆斯
- Ultra Juicy
= Juicy Couture I Am Juicy 我是橘滋
- Unexpected Joy
= Giorgio Armani My Way 自我無界
- Unusual Gourmand
= Ariana Grande God Is A Woman神似女孩
- Unusual Wood
= Juliette Has A Gun Not A Perfume 我不是香水
- Velvet Shadow
= Parfums de Marly Oriana 歐麗安娜
- Vetiver Pamplemousse
= Hermès Eau de Pamplemousse Rose 粉紅葡萄柚
- Vetiver Pamplemousse
= Jo Malone Grapefruit 葡萄柚
- Vibrant Leather
= Creed Aventus 拿破崙
- Vibrant Leather Epicé
= Cartier Déclaration 宣言
- Vibrant Leather For Her
= Creed Aventus For Her 拿破崙(女性)
- Vibrant Leather Metal
= Viktor & Rolf Spicebomb 激情炸彈
- Vibrant Leather Platinum
= Parfums de Marly Pegasus 飛馬
- Vibrant Leather Summer
= Creed Virgin Island Water 維京之泉
- Violet Blossom
= Thierry Mugler Alien 異形
- W/END till 3:00 AM
= Paco Rabanne Black XS 叛逆公主
- W/END till 8:00 PM
= Paco Rabanne Invictus 勇者
- Warm Black
= Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille 午夜香草
- Waterfall Brume
= Hermès Le Jardin de Monsieur Li 李先生的花園
- Waterlily Tea Dress
= Byredo Gypsy Water 吉普賽之水
- Wednesday – I’m Most Grateful
= Byredo Mojave Ghost 莫哈维之影
- White
= Lancôme Miracle 奇蹟
- Winter Collection
= Byredo Bal d'Afrique 熱帶爵士
- Woman Cherry
= Moschino Toy 2
- Woman Gold
= Paco Rabanne Lady Million
- Wonder Rose
= Dolce & Gabbana Dolce Rose 唯戀玫瑰
- Wonder Rose
= Lacoste Pour Elle Sparkling 鱷魚之水
- Wonder Rose So Intense
= Lanvin Modern Princess
- Wood Noir
= Tom Ford Noir Extreme 極致暗黑
- Y Collection
= Yves Saint Laurent La Nuit de l’Homme 天之驕子夜幕版
- 10.0
= Bvlgari Aqva Pour Homme Marine 活力海洋
- 7.0 Zara
= Burberry For Men 倫敦男士
- 9.0 Zara
= Valentino Uomo / Valentino Uomo
----------------------------
平替與抄襲:
----------------------------
簡單來說
就是用更便宜的價格
買到知名香水的氣味
國外常用dupe(抄襲)這個字
而我覺得應該稱作平替(平價替換)
使用的主香調相近
不代表製作過程一樣
其實
每一瓶香水不會100%一樣
即便是同一家品牌、同一家香水
不同生產時間也會有不同味道
如果你是為了100%替換而買它
或是為了紀念而買它
期望越大,失望就會越大
對用習慣的人而言,平替就是不一樣
然而,如果你是以蒐集為主
對香味不苛求
而且是一位小資族
我則會建議你試試看zara香水
台北京站有實體店面
----------------------------
zara香水普遍的評價:
----------------------------
1. 不自然 :開頭味道不自然(我是覺得還好)
2. 便宜 :通常台幣1000以內
3. 單調 :幾乎無變化、結構不豐富
4. 留香短:持香能力差
5. 相似度:大約在75~90%之間
(真的很像,問到味道可以聯想到原廠牌
而且遠遠聞,聞不太出差異)
6. 瓶子爛:噴頭真的爛
7. 偏甜 :相較之下比較甜
----------------------------
心得:
----------------------------
zara本身還是有很多好香水
仿冒與否、交給法律處理
不過,無論你是要找平替
還是為了便宜而買
都建議你先實體聞過味道
在進行購買